New York

Usual 25 man:

Catchers

Bill Dickey 1933-39
Yogi Berra 1950-56

1B

Lou Gehrig 1927-33
Don Mattingly 1984-90

2B

Robinson Cano 2007-13
Tony Lazzeri 1927-33

3B

Alex Rodriguez 2004-10

SS

Derek Jeter 1997-03
Phil Rizzuto 1941-42, 46-50

OF

Babe Ruth 1921-27
Mickey Mantle 1955-61
Joe DiMaggio 1937-42, 46
Charlie Keller 1939-43, 46
Bernie Williams 1995-01

Rotation

Bob Shawkey 1916-17, 19-23
Lefty Gomez 1931-37
Ray Caldwell 1911-17
Roger Clemens 1999-03
Waite Hoyt 1921-27

Bullpen

Mariano Rivera 2003-09
David Robertson 2009-14
Goose Gossage 1978-83
Sparky Lyle 1972-78
Herb Pennock 1923-29
Red Ruffing 1932-38

Other cards made:

Whitey Ford SP 1958-64
Mike Mussina SP 2001-07
Dave Righetti RP 1981-87